THE
LAW OF SEAFARERS
Atty. LeonardoVinz O. Ignacio
The meaning of due process
NO WORKER shall be dismissed except for a just or authorized
cause provided by law and after due process. Under our laws, the shipowner’s
reason or cause for terminating a seaman’s employment is as important as
the manner or procedure it is done.
In the event that the manner or procedure is inappropriate,
the termination itself is defective and may be declared unjustified. A
seaman cannot be automatically repatriated or sent home to the country
without complying with the due process of law.
What then is the meaning of “due process” in terminating
a seaman’s employment?
In brief, due process in dismissal cases entails compliance
with the twin requirements of due notice and hearing. The procedure conforming
to these requirements are as follows:
a) The employer shall furnish the worker a written notice
containing a statement of the cause(s) for dismissal;
b) The workers given ample opportunity to be heard and
to defend himself with the assistance of a representative, if he so desires;
and
c) The decision is made by the employer without prejudice
to the right of the worker to contest the validity or legality of the dismissal
by filing a complaint with the proper authorities. At this point, the burden
of proof to justify the dismissal shall rest on the employer.
These guidelines mandate that the employer furnish an
employee sought to be dismissed copies of written notices of dismissal
before a termination of employment can be legally affected. These are the
notices which apprise the employee of the particular acts or omission for
which the dismissal is sought and the subsequent notice which informs the
employee of the employer’s decision to dismiss him. (National Services
Corporation vs NLRC, 168 SCRA 122) These requirements must be observed.
Likewise, a reading of the guidelines in consonance with the expressed
provision of law on protection to labor (which encompasses the right to
security of tenure) and the broader dictates of procedural due process
necessarily mandates that notice of the employer’s decision to dismiss
an employee, with the reason thereof, can only be issued after the employer’s
has afforded the employee concerned ample opportunity to be heard and to
defend himself. (ibid). Failure to comply with the requirements taints
the dismissal with illegality. This procedure is mandatory, in the absence
of which any judgment reached by management is void and existent. (Tingson
Jr. vs NLRC, 185 SCRA 498) These twin requirements of notice and hearing
constitute the essential element of due process, and neither of these elements
can be eliminated without running afoul of the constitutional guaranty.
(Vinta Maritime Co, Inc.vs NLRC,284 SCRA 656)
Moreover, in the case of Banawa vs NLRC, 251 SCRA 515,
the Supreme Court correctly ruled that due process is so crucial in
termination proceedings that it should not be lightly set aside, most especially
where the incident transpired in a foreign land and the dismissed seaman
was left alone to fend for himself. A manning contract involves the interest
of not only the signatories thereto, such as the local Filipino recruiting
agents, the foreign owner of the vessels and the Filipino seamen in general,
as well as the country’s itself. The stringent rules governing Filipino
seamen aboard foreign-going ships are dictated by national interest.
Lastly, in the case of Puerto Azul Beach Hotel vs Sisayan,
15 SCRA 126, the Supreme Court rightfully held:
“The provision of the Labor Code on notice and hearing
being essential before an employee may be dismissed are too basic for employers
to ignore. In the heat of anger, an employer may scold an employee and
require him to explain or get out of firm. This verbal outburst cannot
take the place of the mandatory written notice. Employers should have learned
by now how to deal with this situation. It does not serve the purpose of
labor legislation or the protections of the due process clause if the Court
allows verbal notices, flatly refuted or denied by the worker, to take
the place of formal notices,” (Underscoring supplied.)
With these in light, a ship owner must and shall conform
to the twin requirements of notice and hearing before terminating a seaman’s
employment. This is in consonance with the principle of due process, which
in general, means simply that before a seaman may be held bound by any
proceeding, where it be for disciplinary or termination purposes, he should
be notified thereof and thus be given an opportunity to defend himself.
The manner or procedure of terminating one’s employment must and shall
conform to this standard in order for such to be impressed with the stamp
of validity like any deprivation of life, liberty and property. This is
because a seaman’s employment is considered property and “NO PERSON SHALL
BE DEPRIVED OF THE LIFE, LIBERTY OR PROPERTY WITHOUT DUE PROCESS OF LAW.”
(The author is formerly the chief of the Legal and
Enforcement Division of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC).
He is presently an attorney with admiralty and labor laws as his main concern
at the Sapalo & Velez Law Offices, 11th Floor, Security Bank Center,
6776 Ayala Avenue, Makati City, tel. no. 891-13-16. He is also a professor
of law at the College of Law, Manuel L. Quezon University.) |
|
OPINION
EDITORIAL
Seafarers’
patriotic duties
SOUNDING LEAD
Seafarers
have spoken
Capt. Reynold M. Sabay
UGONG NG MAKINA
AT IKOT NG ELISE
Sobra
sa training kulang sa galing
Engr. Nelson P. Ramirez
SPIRITUAL VOYAGE
Thanks,
the most forgotten word
David B. Toring Jr., AOS-Cebu
VAST HORIZON
The
grace of humility
C/Engr. Rodolfo B. Virtudazo
THE LAW OF SEAFARERS
The
meaning of due process
Atty. LeonardoVinz O. Ignacio
COMMENT
The
POEA mess,
a
deadly trap
Capt. Leuel P. Oseña
Contribute your ideas online!
Express your opinion!
You can now
any discussion on seafarer's issues anytime or anywhere you are with
Usapang
Marino
(Seafarer's
Forum)
at URL: http://www.ufs.ph/phpBB2
Want to play
basketball while in Rotterdam?
Filipino Seafarers who want
to play basketball on Sundays in Rotterdam, please contact Doming Malaloan
at Tel. No.: 010-463635 or International Seamen's Centre, Heijplaat, Rotterdam,
Tel. No.: 4290702 |
THE
SEAMAN’S CHURCH INSTITUTE OF NY & NJ
International Seafarers’
Center
118 Export Street, Port
Newark,
New Jersey 07114
TELEPHONE (973) 589-5828
FAX (973) 8565
WE WELCOME YOU!
– MON - FRI 8:30 AM to10
PM
– SATURDAY 4 to10 PM
– SUNDAY 4 to 10 PM
Free Transportation to the
center / Worship service, prayer meetings, and counseling is provided aboard
ship by request, and the Mariner’s Chapel / Cross & Anchor calling
cards – low rates for domestic and international calls ($10 and $20 cards
available) / Books, Bibles, magazines, religious materials, trucker resources,
and used clothing / Postal services (U.S. mail, priority / express mail,
Fedex) available / Money orders and money gram services to all countries
/ Cash remittance to the Philippines / Internet access, email services,
faxes / Sports & Entertainment–large screen TV, ping pong, darts, billiards,
soccer, basketball, and video games / Fitness Center / Shower–no charge
for seafarers / Gift Shop–candy, greeting cards, soda, souvenirs, health
and beauty products, clothing / New Jersey Gardens–the largest outlet mall
in NJ just 15 minutes away / Bus service is available / Balikbayan box
shopping, UPS / Restaurant / Bar–Breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
Serving the ports of Newark,
Elizabeth, Jersey City, Bayonne, Port Reading, Kearny, Linden, Carteret,
Perth Amboy, Staten Island, and Brooklyn |
|